Fredonia, NY retail market
Fredonia's commercial retail market is characterized by modest transaction volume focused primarily along Main Street and Water Street, with values heavily shaped by student foot traffic from SUNY Fredonia and local independent tenancy. Sale prices for mixed-use storefront and street retail typically range from $50 to $80 per square foot, with stabilized net-leased retail and restaurant assets achieving higher valuations. Due to limited closed retail sales in Fredonia during the 12-month window, the search was expanded to include nearby Dunkirk and active local offerings.
What's driving Retail prices in Fredonia
Commercial retail property values in the submarket have remained essentially flat with stable yield requirements.
- SUNY Fredonia student body driving village foot traffic and downtown retail sales
- Limited new inventory insulating downtown brick storefront occupancy
Market intelligence
Tracking this market since Nov 2026 · 5 comps · latest deal Oct 2024.
This quarter: 2 comps added to our corpus in Q4 2026. Trend medians use closed-deal dates from our growing comp corpus; automated estimates, not an appraisal.
Where these comps are
Momentum FlatPins are geocoded from each comp's public address, so positions are approximate. Comps quoted at the submarket level aren't pinned.
Recent Retail comps in Fredonia, NY
| Address | Date | Type | Size (SF) | Center Type | Anchor | Price / Rate | $/SF | Tenancy | Year Built |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 61-63 E Main St, Westfield, NY estimate | Oct 2024 | Sale | 3500 | Storefront Retail | Unanchored | $175,000 | $50 | Multi-tenant | 1900 |
| 33-35 E Main St, Fredonia, NY estimate | Active | Sale | 4301 | Storefront Retail | Unanchored | $299,900 | $70 | Multi-tenant | 1930 |
| 36 W Main St, Fredonia, NY listing | Active | Sale | 4797 | Storefront Retail | Unanchored | $259,900 | $54 | Multi-tenant | 1900 |
| 12-14 Water St, Fredonia, NY estimate | Active | Sale | 2208 | Storefront Retail | Unanchored | $349,000 | $158 | Owner-user | 1923 |
| Median of 4 recent sales · $62/SF | $62 | ||||||||
No comps in this filter.
What's your retail property worth?
Get a free, instant estimate from recent comps, with the source cited on every one.
Other markets
Figures are automated estimates derived from public listings, records, and brokerage announcements for Fredonia, NY, not an appraisal or a broker opinion of value. Verify independently before relying on them. CompNinja connects owners with licensed local brokers; it is not a brokerage.